Water Heater Finder | Llewellyn Plumbing

Step 1 of 5 · Fuel Type

Does your water heater use natural gas, propane, or electric?

This determines what type of water heater will work in your home and affects the installation requirements.

Step 2 of 4 · Your Current Setup

What type of venting does your current water heater have?

This is the most important question — the venting type determines what we can replace it with and affects the price significantly.

💡 How to tell which type you have

Look at the pipe coming out of the top of your water heater:

🔸 Aluminum/metal flue pipe going up through the ceiling or wall → Atmospheric Vent (standard)

🔹 White PVC plastic pipe going out the side of the house or up through the roof → Power Vent or Direct Vent

If you have a tankless water heater already, select that option below.

🔧

Atmospheric Vent

Standard metal flue pipe going up through ceiling or roof. Most common in older homes.

Aluminum/metal pipe

💨

Power Vent / Direct Vent

White PVC pipe exits through the side of the house or roof. More modern and efficient.

White PVC pipe

⚡

Already Tankless

I currently have a tankless water heater that needs to be replaced.

Wall-mounted unit

🤔

Not Sure

I can't tell which type I have or I'd rather have someone come look.

I need help identifying

Step 3 of 5 · Our Recommendation

Good news — you're in the perfect position to go tankless 🔥

Your existing power vent setup is already compatible with a Navien tankless system. This makes the conversion more straightforward — and honestly, at these prices, tankless is often the smarter choice.

🪣

Stay with Tank

$3,450 – $3,550

40 or 50 gallon
8–12 year lifespan
6 yr warranty
Same hot water limits

We Recommend This

🔥

Go Tankless

$3,200 – $3,700

Endless hot water
20+ year lifespan
15 yr heat exchanger warranty
24–34% energy savings

💡 Why we push tankless here: With power vent pricing starting at $3,450 for a tank, tankless starts at just $3,200 — and goes up to $3,700 depending on your setup. You get a system that lasts twice as long, never runs out of hot water, and saves you money every month on your energy bill. For most homeowners in your situation, tankless is the better value.

Step 4 of 5 · Your Home

How many people live in your home?

This helps us determine the right size and whether a tank or tankless will best handle your household's hot water demand.

Step 5 of 5 · Your Priority

What matters most to you?

There's no wrong answer — this helps us point you toward the system that fits your situation best.

	🪣 Tank	🔥 Tankless
Upfront cost	Lower	Higher
Monthly energy bill	Higher	24–34% savings
Hot water supply	Limited by tank size	Endless
Lifespan	8–12 years	20+ years
Warranty	6 year avg	15 yr heat exchanger
Space	Large tank	Wall-mounted
Install complexity	Simple	More involved

Next Step · Free Consultation

Let's schedule your free in-home visit

⚠️ In-Person Visit Recommended

Based on your answers, we'd like to come take a look in person before giving you a quote. It's completely free.

✓

Free on-site assessmentWe assess your venting, space, and current setup

✓

No-surprise written quoteExact price upfront — pan, straps, expansion tank all included

✓

Zero pressureWe're plumbers, not salespeople

📱 Text Us to Schedule & Save $100

Tap below — your phone opens a pre-written text with your details already filled in. Attach a photo of your water heater and let us know your preferred day/time to lock in your $100 discount!

On a desktop? Call us at (801) 899-9431 — mention this tool for your $100 off

Your Recommendation

Here's what we recommend 🎯

🔥

—

Starting Price (Installed)

—

Includes pan, expansion tank & seismic straps. Exact quote at your free visit.

🔥

🎉

Save $100

Text us your results right now and book your appointment

$100 off your total invoice when you text us today and schedule

📸 Attach a photo of your water heater to guarantee your price — no photo means we can't guarantee the quote until we see it in person

📅 Schedule when you text — let us know your preferred day and time and we'll confirm right away

💰 $100 off your invoice — applied automatically when you book today

After tapping, attach a photo of your water heater before hitting send

📸 How to attach your photo

1️⃣

Tap the button above to open your text app

2️⃣

Tap the 📎 or 📷 icon to attach a photo of your water heater

3️⃣

Hit send — we'll confirm your price and schedule right away!

Prefer to call? (801) 899-9431 — mention this tool to get your $100 off

Find Your PerfectWater Heater

📱 Text Us to Schedule & Save $100

Find Your Perfect
Water Heater